SMS Marketing Disasters – and How to Avoid Them
Here at FastSMS, we passionately believe that SMS Marketing, also known as text message marketing, is a powerful and cost efficient marketing tool when used correctly. However, as we have covered in recent posts, there are rules and legislation to abide by. If the law is not followed, then it leaves businesses facing enforcement action, whether or not their actions were due to lack of knowledge, being careless or was intentional.
So following on from our articles on some of the laws surrounding marketing by SMS text messages, we are going to take a look at some recent real life examples where companies were punished as a result of their text communications with customers, what happened and how to avoid making the same mistakes.
Provident Personal Credit Ltd (Satsuma Loans)
In July this year, the Information Commissioner’s Office (ICO) published enforcement action it had taken against Provident Personal Credit Ltd, based in Bradford, West Yorkshire. They were found to have sent almost a million text messages through third party affiliates promoting Satsuma Personal Loans over 6 months, although it is possible that a higher number were sent. How did they break the law? The messages were unsolicited, none of the customers had consented to receive such marketing.
The ICO ruled that PPC Ltd had contravened regulation 22 of the Privacy and Electronic Communications (EC Directive) Regulations 2003. This effectively states that senders should not transmit or instigate the transmission of electronic mail for direct marketing purposes unless the recipient of the mail has previously notified the sender that they consent freely and specifically to such communications.
The ICO’s spam reporting service had received 285 complaints regarding this company’s campaign between 6th April 2015 and 13th October 2015. After the ICO investigated, they issued a monetary penalty, or fine, of £80,000 under section 55a of the Data Protection Act 1998. PPC Ltd will have the right to appeal this.
The Head of Enforcement for the ICO, Steve Eckersley commented: “The law is clear. You can’t send marketing texts to people who have not signed up to receive them.
“Being bombarded with texts you didn’t ask for and don’t want is an intrusion into people’s privacy, an irritation and, in the worst cases can be upsetting. Companies have no excuse whatsoever for sending nuisance texts, whether they do it themselves or employ someone else to do it for them.”
The company released a statement about the action: ‘’Although the ICO found that the contravention was not deliberate, PPC takes this contravention extremely seriously. It has reviewed its marketing processes and put in place procedures designed to prevent such conduct happening again’’.
There have been several other businesses fined by the ICO within the last year for breaches of the DPA or PECR during SMS text messaging direct marketing campaigns.
The key to preventing any such problems in your business is to ensure that you or at least one competent member of your staff maintain an understanding of privacy and data legislations and double check each campaign to ensure they meet the rules. Don’t leave things to chance – seek advice from a correctly accredited provider when unsure as the legislation can be complicated.
Clean Carpets Plymouth
Although this case centres around a contractual argument rather than direct marketing, it definitely provides a clear example of how not to deal with customers by text. On 7th February this year, a newspaper article in the Plymouth Herald, later picked up and published by some of the national tabloids, alleged that the above company had harassed a young couple through text messages.
The couple had apparently booked a carpet cleaning session but then cancelled due to suffering a miscarriage and hospitalisation as a result. The company felt that the customer had not provided cancellation within the appropriate time and should pay a cancellation fee. What followed was a series of text messages between the company owner and the customer, some of which were printed in the newspaper articles, appearing to show the company taking quite an aggressive stance towards the customer. Each time the customer responded, the company raised their administration fee by £25, so by the end, it reached almost £1000. It was even reported that the carpet cleaning firm had said the couple deserved to lose their baby although they strongly deny this.
The customers reported the company and its owner to the police, who were investigating if a crime had been committed under the Malicious Communications Act 1988. Whether or not any prosecution case will be brought against the company is unknown as of yet, but two days later, another article was published where the company owner claimed that he and his wife had received death threats and risked losing both their business and their home as a result.
Moral of the story? There is such a thing as bad publicity. This may seem a pretty extreme example, but it’s easier than you think for you or your employees to send texts containing inappropriate or easily misconstrued wording or content and this could unravel your company’s reputation and business security quicker than pressing the send button. A poorly trained or resentful employee could wreak havoc so at the very least, make sure you have tight approval protocol systems in place.
For more information on some of the many laws applicable to SMS Marketing, we recommend that you also read the following articles:
A Brief Guide to the Data Protection Act 1998
Steering Clear of Spamming & Harassment
SMS Marketing is one of the lowest cost and most effective forms of marketing available and offers great potential for ROI across every sector. To learn more about how we can help your business to grow with our bulk SMS messaging solutions, get in touch with the friendly and professional team here at Fastsms now and we’ll get you started in no time.
References:
https://www.plymouthherald.co.uk/we-have-lost-everything-carpet-cleaning-couple/story-30121836-detail/story.html
Related Articles
3 Compliance Tips for Your Next SMS Marketing Campaign
When conducting an SMS marketing campaign, there are a number of compliance regulations you should be aware of, to ensure that your communications are as effective as possible, without being potentially damaging to your campaign or your business. If you're marketing to a UK market, the UK Privacy and Electronic Communications Regulations (PECR) gives clear guidelines on what falls within the rules. Here we've highlighted some key tips to ensure your next campaign is compliant, based on common questions that arise.
3 Golden Rules for Sending Your SMS Messages at the Perfect Time of Day
Have you struggled to find the right time to send your SMS messages? Have you gotten complaints because customers found your messages too annoying? You might be sending them out at the wrong time of day. Follow these three simple rules and discover the perfect time for your messages.
Insights Into The Best SMS Marketing
It’s been said that to be successful at something, you need to find someone that’s already done what you want to do, then emulate them. You don’t need to create or rewrite the rulebook every time. This is true of marketing too. While it’s a creative field, there are tried and true examples of what works. This is why case studies are so important to helping you understand how something like SMS marketing can work for you.
7 Channels for “Free Promotion” of Your Opt In Campaigns
While there are many ways you can probably think of to promote your SMS opt in campaign, there may be some “free” channels you’re neglecting. Thanks to Google, I can point out seven of them. At the mCommerce Summit Google gave a presentation about app promotion and optimising. I can’t even convey how exasperated the presenter was when he talked about how many opportunities companies just let slip by.
Sending Your First SMS Marketing Campaign
6 steps to sending your first SMS marketing campaign. Whether you've already decided to use fastsms, or are still trying us out - these simple steps will show you how quickly you can get up and running and sending texts to your customers.
Why you want to keep your SMS marketing database clean
Advantages & Disadvantages of SMS Marketing
SMS marketing is very different to most other more traditional marketing tools, specifically because of its short-form, text only nature. This certainly shouldn't put you off though. We have put together our guide to both the best things about SMS marketing and some of the potential problems, and how to work around them.
How to Choose the Incentive for Your SMS Marketing Opt-In Campaign
You’ve decided to try out SMS marketing. But you’re stuck on that first step of choosing the offer for your initial opt in campaign. Don’t worry, if you know the story of Goldilocks then you’ll understand just what to do after reading this blog.
SMS Marketing Compliance and The New GDPR Regulations
As with anything in business, there are rules and regulations that need to be followed. Some of the key ones are laid out in the UK Privacy and Electronic Communications Regulation (PECR) - and while this can seem like a daunting document at first, it doesn't need to be...
Unsolicited SMS Messages Lead to Trouble…Even for Trump
Late last month reports surfaced that the Trump US presidential campaign had sent unsolicited SMS messages to voters in the Chicago area. One man, Joshua Thorne, and his lawyers have filed a class-action lawsuit alleging the Trump Campaign violated the Telephone Consumer Protection Act (TCPA, the US equivalent of the PECR).