Marketing Review for 2015 Holiday Season
The busy holiday season is gone, but still fresh in our memories. Did things turn out like people thought they might, or did reality turn expected trends on their head? Two major companies published their analysis of the season providing some much needed insight into what might work in 2016.
Experian and Adobe published their reports based on different sources. Each company monitors their own network of retailers and transactions, plus they approach the subject from slightly different viewpoints.
The first report I’ll look at is the Experian Marketing Services Holiday Hot Sheet. It focuses mainly on email marketing, but they’ve also begun to compare email with SMS marketing. The second report is the Adobe 2015 Holiday Shopping Report which looks at spending trends including devices used.
Experian report
The data in the Holiday Hot Sheet is from 40 major brands in the US, but the SMS data only comes from a subset of 20 brands. While that seems like a small number of companies for a general study, the size of the retailers means they likely sent many millions of messages when all added together so the data does have value. With that said, let’s see what they found.
- 34% of SMS messages included the same offer as in their email marketing. The report doesn’t give any information on how well these 34% of messages performed. Best practices for SMS marketing is to make the SMS offers exclusive, and not to duplicate what is sent via email. This is because of the high value of an SMS subscriber – much better conversion rates than with email subscribers and a greater level of trust expected by the subscriber. Marketers tend to go a little crazy at the holiday season, so maybe these offers reflected a multichannel approach rather than business as usual. Either way I’m sure the individual retailers examined their performance to see how these same-as-email offers performed. I can’t help but notice though, that 66% of the messages weren’t duplicates, so that is probably an indication of how well that works.
- 88% included an offer in message. Why wouldn’t they, especially at that time of year? The remaining 12% most likely consisted of order confirmations, shipping notifications, status updates, or account information. Thinking about it now, 12% seems a little low actually for these kind of informational texts during a holiday season. Perhaps many retailers don’t offer SMS confirmations or updates. Or perhaps they just sent a LOT more marketing messages! The report doesn’t offer more in-depth data.
- The most popular offer was a percentage off sale. Other offers included free shipping or a coupon or code. The breakout of offers is in the image below taken from the report. Clearly some messages included more than one offer because the percentages don’t add up to 100%. That’s not too unusual. Many offers for percentages off, will also include a code or coupon that the consumer needs to use.
Adobe report
The Adobe report is based on the transactions that occur on the Adobe Marketing Cloud Solutions. Most of it relates to US retailers, but they do provide some insight into global sales and trends, including the UK.
One of the key data points from the study is that mobile traffic was up year-over-year (YOY). Website traffic from phones was up 9%, while desktop and tablet traffic decreased 6% and 3% respectively. What I found most interesting though is this chart showing the traffic patterns:

The lines indicate website traffic from the various devices. The Phone (and tablet to a lesser degree) almost seems to be responding to the desktop line. When desktop traffic goes down, the phone traffic goes up. Perhaps it isn’t to the magnitude of the desktop traffic, but it is in sync don’t you think? It appears to me that there is some set of people who always use their phone or desktop (where the lines are mostly flat), and then there are the people who switch from the desktop to the phone and back again with some regularity. The scale on the image isn’t enough to tell whether these dips and bumps correspond to a time of day or to certain days of the week. If I had to guess though, I’d say the desktop drops, and phone bumps, happened on weekends and the holidays when people were out going to parties or shopping.
If I’m right, these people are comfortable switching back and forth, which means retailers need to prepared for multichannel shopping. Creating a consistent experience for desktop and mobile users may become more important as additional people begin switching back and forth. Consistency doesn’t mean identical either. Mobile users may want more information via text message rather than email or on the website. But they will want to find something on their phone as easily as they find it on their desktop. They also expect the mobile website to work well – which means they don’t expect the exact same site, just a similar experience.
What mobile devices and OSes do you need support in the coming year? Well, 75% of the sales came from iOS (either phones or tablets). Only 23% came from Android devices. Notice I said sales there and not traffic. For traffic, 35% came from Android devices and 66% used iOS (some small number of “other” devices account for the remaining 1%).
The UK led Europe in total holiday sales, with only the US and China topping them. Germany wasn’t too far behind. But the UK led all countries when it came to consumers shopping from phones or tablets. Just over 40% of online sales came from either a tablet or a phone, with the highest percentage of sales made with tablets than in any other country too.
The Brits are very happy to shop via mobile devices. That’s something to take into next year’s holiday season.
These trends seem to say that the 2016 Holiday season is likely to have even more mobile shoppers. But we aren’t likely to see desktop and tablet sales disappear – yet.
Related Articles
A2P SMS Messaging Market is Complex, But Growing
I came across an interesting article regarding the A2P market. It’s entitled “Growing Employment Rate to Benefit BFSI A2P SMS Market in Switzerland.” The contents summarise a new report from Transparency Market Research about the A2P market in Switzerland, specifically how it relates to BFSI or Banking, Financial Services, and Insurance (BFSI). You might be thinking that sounds boring rather than interesting, but what drew my attention was the relationship of employment to A2P SMS messaging.
How Clubs Can Benefit from Using Text Messaging
Read how clubs can benefit from the use of text messaging services to reduce wasted time and increase customer satisfaction. They can confirm appointments in advance with an option to text back to cancel or re-schedule thus reducing no-shows. SMS is also great for sharing news and special offers with members.
70% of Employees Want Their Employers to Use SMS Messaging
SMS messaging is a terrific way of keeping in touch with employees. Confirm work schedules, notify employees of payroll transfers, chase deadlines and more. What's really great is that the employees themselves really want employers to communicate the way.
The Difference Between Email and SMS Autoresponders: Part 1
While you may be familiar with email autoresponders (especially if you’re in marketing) you may or may not know you can set up a similar function with SMS messaging. In concept, it works the same way. But there are some differences in how they are used which I’ll cover here.
What Do Honey G, Football Manager and SMS Messaging Have in Common?
One of our newest team members is Jordan, who joined us earlier this year. We asked him to answer some questions so our customers could get to know him better. He manages a variety of sectors so take a few moments and find out how Jordan can help you with SMS messaging.
SMS Plays a Key Role in This Massive Marketing Campaign
What do oddly flavoured crisps and SMS messaging have in common? The US version of Walkers brand crisps ran a massive marketing campaign to promote three flavours released for a limited time. Find out how it worked and why SMS played a key role in the process.
The Role of SMS in Building Consumer Loyalty Programmes
The drive to earn and retain consumer loyalty is big business in the UK. Increasingly, companies are grasping the important role SMS text messaging can play in this. Customers’ mobile phone numbers are gold dust. The most forward-looking companies are developing systems to encourage customers to opt-in. Then, they are structuring SMS campaigns to build loyalty and reap maximum commercial advantage from it.
Advice and Predictions for the Future of SMS Messaging in 2017
SMS messaging took off in 2016. And that’s saying something for a technology that’s been around twenty-five years. Come take a look at the past year and see what we think 2017 will bring to the industry and how you can use it in your business.
5 Ways to Use SMS to Save Money and Improve Your Retail Business
Every good retail business owner knows that the key to success is keeping his or her customers happy. Your level of customer service should be all encompassing to succeed and should consist of more than just being polite to the customer at the till.
SMS Messaging is Much Better Than Shouting!
Just in the last 60-70 years, communications have gone from requiring a person to route the calls to not needing anyone other than the two people at either end. It all got me wondering about the history of communications and how much different it is from even just a 100 years ago, or a thousand. The result of my wondering is this infographic that covers most of recorded history (at some level of detail anyway).